Home » Forums » Aviation photography » Pictures from AP on Air Austral Facebook page.
Tom Knops Member Joined in May 2017 Posts: 7 |
Posted 25 October 2018 - 22:34 CET |
Hello everyone,
randomly I was really suprised, because I found my own picture (https://www.airplane-pictures.net/photo/1019826/f-olrc-air-austral-boeing-787-8-dreamliner/) on Air Australs FB page, I was suprised, because I never got an e-mail from them, where they asked me for the permission. And not only my picture is their, also 4 other photos from AP, and other planespotting pages. Does anyone know, if it´s legally for them, to just post the photos me and other´s made, without mentioning the name or even without any permission?
Greetings, Tom Knops
Air Austral Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/AirAustral/ |
Ray Abela Head admin Joined in July 2009 Posts: 367 |
Posted 26 October 2018 - 07:51 CET |
Take a look here
https://www.politico.eu/article/ecj-photographer-permission-ruling/
Ray |
Lien Savo G. S. Member Joined in February 2017 Posts: 128 |
Posted 26 October 2018 - 08:23 CET |
They must pay you, Tom! |
Dominik Kauer Full member Joined in May 2016 Posts: 38 |
Posted 26 October 2018 - 08:45 CET |
Just to make this clear: the pictures are posted on a NON OFFICIAL Air Austral facebook site!
And it even might be grey zone because your name is visible on the botom left corner. Try to talk with the page owner. |
Boytronic Full member Joined in March 2015 Posts: 87 |
Posted 26 October 2018 - 10:04 CET |
Contact Facebook ASAP, make a report. They are very strict about copyrighted contents. Most probably they will remove that page for good. (had a lot of similar situations and every time facebook did as requested) |
Tom Knops Member Joined in May 2017 Posts: 7 |
Posted 26 October 2018 - 10:19 CET |
Hello,
thank you for the quick replies, I will first contact the others and then just report the site.
Greetings, Tom |
Dennis van de Watering Member Joined in December 2015 Posts: 25 |
Posted 26 October 2018 - 17:12 CET |
I don't actually think that in this case it'll be illegal because your name is still visible in the left down corner, as well as the name of AP.net in the right corner. But let's see how facebook will look at it. Maybe i'm wrong. |
Philippe Ardin Member Joined in January 2017 Posts: 15 |
Posted 27 October 2018 - 15:51 CET |
No commercial or business purpose, the author and editor are visible... just a good advertising for you and AP...I'm afraid... Sorry...
Let's see facebook's reaction... |
Philippe Ardin Member Joined in January 2017 Posts: 15 |
Posted 27 October 2018 - 15:56 CET |
PS : AP's watermarks are useful, aren't they ? |
Philipp Goretzka Member Joined in November 2014 Posts: 4 |
Posted 27 October 2018 - 15:59 CET |
HI Tom
Ich denke auch, dass es für dich nur eine Art "gute Werbung" ist. Warum die zwingen das Bild runter zu nehmen? Die werden dir ja sowieso kein Geld geben. Ich würde das einfach gut sein lassen.
Schöne Grüße |
DUB_Spotter Member Joined in July 2016 Posts: 182 |
Posted 28 October 2018 - 09:20 CET |
Does anyone know where I can get a photo theft and used on a site without my consent? I contacted that company but did not want to answer when I told them they had to pay for it. |
DUB_Spotter Member Joined in July 2016 Posts: 182 |
Posted 28 October 2018 - 09:24 CET |
In a first step, i have one answer.
With regards your mail below , please be advise SX-ABE A319 belongs to Olympus Airways S.A , the site is the Olympus Airways official site. With regards your consent it is not required as the aircraft belongs to our company. |
Philippe Ardin Member Joined in January 2017 Posts: 15 |
Posted 28 October 2018 - 11:04 CET |
The question is always complicated : on the one hand you are not supposed to publish for money their logos and trademarks, appearing on the aircraft, without their permission, on the other hand they are not supposed to publish your photos without your permission ... The minimum would be to credit the author on their site : "photo by...".
And don't forget watermarks... |
DUB_Spotter Member Joined in July 2016 Posts: 182 |
Posted 28 October 2018 - 12:41 CET |
@Philippe Ardin The problem is different. The aircraft had no inscription. Posing at a public airport does not require permission to fly an airplane or another regardless of the inscription. The photo stolen by the company had a watermark added, just that they made a crop so as to take out watermarks, and besides, they changed the image by inscribing in Photoshop a logo that would appear to their aircraft. If you want. I'll give you examples. Here are the examples, in the first link found the modified picture on their website, and in the aviation site my initial image.
https://www.olympusairways.gr/a319-132.html?fbclid=IwAR3J7H_l9Ogbp2tfld97PO0qQxXKaltAjX_z3r5UDKfKZWe2yF21soEJk_s
https://www.planespotters.net/photo/699178/sx-abe-olympus-airways-airbus-a319-132 |
Lien Savo G. S. Member Joined in February 2017 Posts: 128 |
Posted 28 October 2018 - 14:06 CET |
PD: It looks really poor the edit made by Olympic Airlines. LOL |
DUB_Spotter Member Joined in July 2016 Posts: 182 |
Posted 29 October 2018 - 19:43 CET |
I sent another mail and told them that if they did not respond to clarifying the situation. I asked 200 euros for using my picture two year ago. If not, they will pay thousands of euros for lawyers, court fees and moral damages. |
Log in to post in the forum.